Home / Arts / Art /  Apathy’s Ugly Twin
  Share
Tuesday, March 17,2009

Apathy’s Ugly Twin

Art Review

By Aisha Motlani
 

Call me a contrarian, but when I perceive mass movement in one direction I usually gravitate toward the other. There's something eerie about public consensus. I hope (but am not entirely convinced) a similar streak of dissent broods beneath the self-consciously seditious surface of UW-Milwaukee Union's newest exhibit (through April 3). Without that glimmer of hope I'd have to dismiss their Justseeds Cooperative show as a noisy and all-too-earnest mass of rebellious statements targeted indiscriminately at ready-made causes.

The exhibition brings a sense of urban dereliction into the rarefied gallery setting-nothing new, except for the theatrical manner in which it's done. The front segment of the gallery, bordered by a barbed, cut-out paper fence, bears the murky feel of a subway station. A gash in the fence allows access to the main body of the gallery, which gives off an air of arid dejection. A broken, grime-streaked concrete overpass inhabits the space, with a fake car teetering over its edge. Instead of disconsolate youths skulking in the shadows of this urban promontory, cardboard wolves pick their way through the wasteland. A lone bear gazes at visitors from a height. The paper-thin animals and a vine of roses lend the exhibit a fabled aura. However, the subtle play between urban and fictional lore is largely blotted out by the bevy of slogans screaming at you from posters plastered to the mock-concrete pillars, and hippie-ish, Earth-hugging catechisms scrawled across the high windows telling you to "turn fear into love" and "dream more." The posters speak out against territorial occupation, racism, worker exploitation, capitalism, highway construction and just about everything else. Here's apathy's annoying twin, cloying concern, rearing its ugly head.

Then again, that may be the point. Perhaps the exhibit is intended not to inspire rebellion but sow doubts about the kind of blanket-fashioned activism that banks on our complicity but ultimately snuffs out all feeling. An image of an index finger pointing upward with a caption that reads "buff this" corroborates this point, bringing to mind a scene from the 1950s cult movie The Wild One. When asked what he's rebelling against, the main character answers "whaddya got?" This, and the fact that the authors remain anonymous, suggests a subtle disavowal. The artwork somehow remains aloof and unclaimed, like the prowling cardboard wolves.

 

POST A COMMENT
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
I'm really surprised at the negativity of this review on the Just Seeds installation. This is by far the best show I have ever seen at the UWM Union Art Gallery. This show is is refreshingly aggressive in its strong declarations. I don't understand the statement in this review "nothing new." Surely many of the topics presented (social inequalities, worker's rights, and environmentalism to name a few) are popular, however I have never seen a show that illustrated these topics by transforming a gallery space so drastically. Amidst the ruinous highway plants and animals return to their ancestral environments. Amongst the dark and gloomy subject matter are embedded symbols of hope. Birds in flight, symbols of resistance, and a pile of paper air planes to be thrown about (as well as paper to build your own plane) add a splash of positive energy. Unlike traditional gallery spaces the Just Seeds show forces you to break down your subconscious boundaries whether it is ignoring the "Keep Out" sign at the entrance, breaking through a barbed wire fence, or infiltrating paper barriers to view hidden artwork. I would highly suggest you see the show and decide for yourself!

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
I have always thought that art could and should have a voice in shaping a political debate. Yet I remained unconvinced and distanced walking through Justseeds exhibit at UWM Union Gallery. I agree with the point made by Aisha Motlani, that the show addressed a number of popular (ready-made) causes, on which there is pretty much a general consensus, and no convincing of anybody is necessary. What I could not see, was an expression of genuine engagement in a particular subject that would have great relevance to the artist, and was directed towards bringing an actual change. The verbal language used by the artists reminds me of manifestos by Russian avant-garde artists such as Malewicz or Lissitsky, who wanted to support building of the new proletarian society in the Soviet Union. But they also strongly believed that only a radically new visual language would be effective in bringing change. The imagery in the show felt recycled, weakening the already obvious message. Justseeds is a great idea and has a potential to be an important voice. But I think that the bar must be raised and real risks taken.

 

 
 
Today in Milwaukee
SAG_Click2012.jpg
BOM_Winners_410x93.jpg
ShepDrink_092911_410x93.jpg
Cover_300x344_02_23_12.jpg

Join Us at Facebook, Twitter, MySpace and Flickr


 
 
 
*/?>