Home / News / Expresso /  Issue of the Week: Fake Jobs, Real Session
  Share
Wednesday, October 5,2011

Issue of the Week: Fake Jobs, Real Session

Plus Hero of the Week

By Shepherd Express Staff
 
Last week Gov. Scott Walker announced his new jobs bill, along with a special session of the state Legislature in which to fast-track it.

But don't be fooled by Walker's sudden concern for the state's jobless. He couldn't be less sincere.

Walker's bill has been roundly panned by Democrats and their allies for its lack of valid solutions for the state's stubborn unemployment problem. While Walker did make the politically smart move of including a few Democratic proposals, his bill was mostly made up of tax breaks that wouldn't result in any significant hiring.

Walker's bill is so unfocused on jobs that it includes "tort reform" to shield manufacturers of defective medical devices from lawsuits. Perhaps it'll save jobs at negligent manufacturers' workplaces, but is that really good public policy?

Walker also proposes to lower large manufacturers' energy bills. But that only means that other ratepayers would have to foot the bill.

Even worse, Walker's alleged jobs bill would help ease the way for a proposed iron ore mine in northern Wisconsin. True, Wisconsin has a proud history of mining. But Walker's proposal has been criticized as a way to promote his donors' and allies' business interests at the expense of Wisconsin's common good. The issue is too important to be included as an afterthought in a larger bill.

Even though Walker's jobs bill is a sham, the rubber-stamp Republican majorities in the state Legislature are more than likely going to do his bidding. They're going to ram through the rest of Walker's wish list while he's still in office. With Walker dogged by high disapproval ratings and questions surrounding a John Doe investigation, the clock is ticking.

Although Madison Republicans are likely to give Walker everything he wants, no matter how little it will do for the state's unemployed, congressional Republicans are refusing to work with President Obama and his far more serious, far more productive job-creation package. Obama has proposed to give tax breaks to workers, not billionaires; invest in infrastructure repair and public employees; and help folks who have been out of work for more than six months. The president has his priorities right. Why doesn't the governor?

Heroes of the Week

Dominican Center for Women Volunteers

The Milwaukee nonprofit group Dominican Center for Women (DCW), founded in Minneapolis in 1990 by Sister Ann Halloran and Sister Anne-Marie Doyle, continues its mission of breaking the cycle of poverty and improving living conditions for program participants.

Volunteers play a vital role in DCW's success. Based on the notion that a proper education is key to economic well-being, the Adult Education Program offers one-on-one tutoring for basic reading, writing and math skills, as well as computer instruction. Also, because those living in poverty are often unable to afford upkeep on their homes, resulting in potentially unsafe environments, DCW volunteers help participants with needed improvements to make living quarters healthy and safe.

Readers interested in tutoring or donating their skills to the Housing Rehab Program are encouraged to call 414-444-9930 or visit www.dominican-center.org.

 

POST A COMMENT
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
I am always disappointed when government officials try to create a "jobs bill". The goverment cannot create real jobs. Sure they candy coat tax breaks as a jobs bill. I will agree with the liberals that it is a sham. There are plenty of jobs and the economy is booming. Maybe not across the street from where unemployed cowards live but there are loads and loads of jobs. Jobs are always and everywhere all the time. It just take a little gumption and ambition. People who don't have jobs just arn't trying hard enough. Mid Texas, North Dakota - huge worker shortages in the oil and gas fields. Look at all the new retail stores being built in Wisconson. Look at all the Walmarts opening. Loads and loads of jobs. Unfortunatley Scott Walker cannot make people get off their butts and move to where the jobs are. He's stuck with these cowards and is trying to help them.

 

David, then why don't YOU get together with your fellows, create amnesty for all these lazy people's debts, and then give their entire family a free one-way ticket to where those jobs are? You will be doing a valuable service to the banks that hold those debts, making them whole again, and also removing these people from being "in the faces" of the "good" people that remain?

And if they still refuse to work, let that next area deal with them!

 

Unemployment is not the problem.  People are the problem.  There are two kinds of unemployed. First cowards and the lazy.  They will not move to the jobs, they will not put aside their dignity and take the work that is available.  The others are the unemployable.  Those that have self inflicted issues like tats and piercings, overweight, etc.  They have pretty much blown it.

The first group just needs to man up.  The second group needs to grow up. 


 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
True, government cannot "create jobs" in the private sector. Also, it's true that there are lots of jobs out there. However, Mr. Livingston, jobs like cashiering at Wal-Mart are poorly-paid and do not offer livable wages or sufficient benefits. I know unemployed people looking for jobs and no, they will not be working at Wal-Mart because it would be a waste of their time--they will not be able to make ends meet anyways. Yes, there are always jobs...if you want to earn some money you can also sell illicit drugs or resort to prostitution, but like working at Wal-Mart, these are not ideal. Actual minimum wage continues to decline, while incomes for large stakeholders in companies like Wal-Mart continue to rise. The problem is not that people are lazy, it is that they have dignity. Openings in technical positions such as in oil fields require training and education. Unemployed people can't simply step into a job like this. To an unemployed, middle-aged person, going back to school can also be frightening, since they are facing taking on more debt with no certainty of actually being able to pay it off (after all, they might still be job hunting for years after graduation or certification). Perhaps the government could REALLY help to create jobs by offering to foot the bill for education of new technical hires. Throwing out a generic tax break offers no assurance that a company will do any long-term good for a state or community.

 

Unfortunately there are no jobs out their paying good wages to those without the mental wherewithal to work.  Lets face it, they will have to work the Walmart type jobs.  Dignity? They need to get over it.  Many unemployed have screwed up by not saving and investing wisely.  Too many have banked on having one job or one employer.  They gambled their livelyhood and lost, just like at the Blackjack table in Vegas.  No bailouts.  They didn't know how to play the cards.  If you think some politician or tax break is going to create a well paying job across the street from where you live and they are going to come and recruit you -- wake up.  Not happening.  Getting a well paying job takes drive, abition, gumption, networking, persistence.  Often it mean moving hundreds or thousands of miles away. You can't pay people good wages to sit around and be stupid.  They have to be able to use some skill or talent.  If they have no ability to produce goods and services that produce big profits, then there is no use for them.  Therefore they will only need to know three words -  "Wecome to Walmart."

 

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Anonymous, your attitude is reflective of the root of the problem in this country (and moreover, the world). You are an idealist who believes that people who work hard get good things and that everyone who is poor deserves it because those people are lazy. I presume you are employed and take credit for every good thing in your life. If you can't take credit for all the good things in your life, then you would have an unfair advantage over those around you because they are all 100% responsible for their own situations. You demonize the unemployed as lacking "mental wherewithal" and being "stupid". By this attitude, I presume you have found your successes in life only by means of your superior intellect. It would be incongruous with your post above if the truth were that you yourself ever had a relative, friend, or someone else you knew who might have helped you get a job, pay some debt, or finish college. Perhaps you are black, you were born into an impoverished family and you now make a lot of money putting your brain to good use. In that case, you have overcome many challenges. You must have gumption, drive, and ambition. You must also have persistence! None of those words is remotely synonymous with the other, is it? Nevermind that--you are a successful human because you are smart. As for the rest of the stupid, lazy world...it's their own fault they are poor. Look at Wall Street...they are all just very hard-working people; surely none of these billionaires were born into billionaire families. The world really is a level playing field, especially in the US of A! God bless this wonderful country. But kill all illegal immigrants, am i right? (*wink wink nudge nudge*)

 

I give credit to God.  Everyday he blesses me with more than I deserve.  Even in bad times the blessings keep coming.  When I'm out of work all I have to do is go to Vegas, put on my monkey suit, dance for them man, and prospect for new business.  It comes without fail.  Sure I could sit at home waiting for Obama to pass a jobs bill.  But instead I take the initiative and travel to where the decision makers are, the guys who hire and write the checks.  I convince them to hire me and fire the guy they have working for them now.  I'm in a "short term" contract business so I must be constantly looking for work.  Once you get used to finding  a new job 2-3 times a year, it becomes old hat and easy to do.  Like learning to fish, once you know how and where to look, its easy.  Maybe I'm lucky because so many people just don't try hard enough or know how to get a job.  I don't have to be very smart or ambitious.  All I have to do is be smarter and more abitious than you.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Anonymous, you sound like a prospector of old! Congratulations on being able to move around and earn an income through contracts throughout the nation. What if you were to become ill and unable to travel, or if you had a family that needed you at home, thus preventing you to move around? What if you had no experience in any particular trade and nobody wanted to hire you? There are many things that constrict people's abilities to travel. My point is simply that a large percentage of how a person's life plays out is up to chance, and events outside of a person's control. It is convenient for the successful to take credit for success or else assign it to some imaginary source that everyone supposedly has access to (god, public education, insert your source here...). Much less convenient is the daily unkind realities of our current social and political systems. These things are broken toys, mangled by the super-wealthy and soon to be abandoned altogether. You seem to be quite seasoned and able to work inside this broken system, but you would be ignorant to say that all citizens have the same ability or should be expected to rise to the same level as you on their own. It would be like if I were an athlete running a 1600m race in 4:30 and expecting my friend with spina bifida to do the same. This is a hyperbole, so I hope you will excuse it, but I don't want you to miss the illustration. Not all people are given the same advantages and we can not all be expected to perform to the same level with this system of uneven advantage. Perhaps if Jesus Christ were president, he might be in favor of helping these disadvantaged folks. As for myself (who you must be smarter and more ambitious than), I am employed only in one location. It's a relatively well-paid job which I got because my parents were good enough to see me through a decent high-school education and pay my way through college. Like you, I am grateful. I just wish that other people around me who are less fortunate could be given something else to be grateful for as well.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
The war of the classes has begun, Step up to the podium..David.I would rather live in a culvert then work at Wal-Mart. I think they should close the Wal-Marts. Put the Mom and Pop's back in business. I'm picking cotton soon in AZ. karen

 

 
 
Today in Milwaukee
CityGuide2012_banner_410x93_040512.jpg
SpringGuideToHigherEd2012_410x93.jpg
SAG_Click2012.jpg
Express234x120.gif

Join Us at Facebook, Twitter, MySpace and Flickr


 
 
 
*/?>