Home News Features Gableman’s Tough-on-Crime Message Doesn’t Match Reco
Wednesday, March 12,2008
Share
Gableman’s Tough-on-Crime Message Doesn’t Match Reco
If you only watched the campaign ads, you would
think that Supreme Court justices are the ultimate crime-fighters in the
state. Even if that were true, you may want to think twice about
Burnett County Circuit Court Judge Michael Gableman’s record as a
prosecutor and judge.
The truth is Gableman has only won one felony jury prosecution in his entire career. As a judge, one-third of his rulings were overturned—a very weak record. Yet in his campaign biography, Gableman calls himself a “law and order judge” who also was “the lead prosecutor on cases as diverse as arson, sexual assault, domestic violence and white-collar crimes.”
In his campaign ads, Gableman follows the standard conservative, corporate-backed judicial playbook. Be “tough on crime.” Pose in front of a police car. Get endorsements from Republican DAs. Bash your opponent for being “soft on crime.”
Gableman was a prosecutor in Langlade and Marathon counties for three years before becoming a judge. As Ashland County DA, Gableman says, he took on arsonists. TV ads sponsored by the conservative Club for Growth and Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce (WMC) also tout his arson-slaying record, as well as other crime-fighting achievements.
But did Gableman really fight northern Wisconsin arsonists—and win? An exhaustive search of online records in Wisconsin’s Consolidated Court Automation Programs (CCAP) database only turns up one arson case that Gableman put before a jury.
And Gableman lost the case. Calls to Gableman’s campaign, the Club for Growth and WMC to confirm their campaign statements went unreturned. What about Gableman’s other tough-on-crime successes? CCAP only lists nine individual felony jury cases naming Gableman as the prosecutor in Ashland County. Although nine different case numbers are listed, only six trials took place because some of the defendants had multiple cases that were consolidated.
These felony cases involved charges such as witness intimidation, sexual assault of a child, robbery, arson, substantial battery and felony child abuse. Gableman only managed to win two of those six trials—a theft from business and a sexual assault of a child case. Five years after winning the sexual assault case, the matter was dismissed on appeal to a higher court.
That leaves Gableman with only one successfully prosecuted felony jury case. So that’s the reality behind the campaign claims. But another reality is that state Supreme Court justices aren’t really crime-fighters who lock up the bad guys and throw out the key. Rather, they apply legal precedents to cases that have been tried by juries and appealed by lawyers— both prosecutors and defense attorneys who think that their clients have been wrongly convicted. (It has been known to happen. Would you want to change places with the innocent civil servant Georgia Thompson, who was convicted by a jury and served time in prison before her case was overturned by a federal appellate court?) So while right-wing groups such as the Club for Growth and WMC want to bamboozle voters into believing that a Supreme Court justice can single-handedly toss alleged arsonists and other baddies into jail, think again. That isn’t reality.
What’s your take? Write: editor@shepex.com.
The truth is Gableman has only won one felony jury prosecution in his entire career. As a judge, one-third of his rulings were overturned—a very weak record. Yet in his campaign biography, Gableman calls himself a “law and order judge” who also was “the lead prosecutor on cases as diverse as arson, sexual assault, domestic violence and white-collar crimes.”
In his campaign ads, Gableman follows the standard conservative, corporate-backed judicial playbook. Be “tough on crime.” Pose in front of a police car. Get endorsements from Republican DAs. Bash your opponent for being “soft on crime.”
Gableman was a prosecutor in Langlade and Marathon counties for three years before becoming a judge. As Ashland County DA, Gableman says, he took on arsonists. TV ads sponsored by the conservative Club for Growth and Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce (WMC) also tout his arson-slaying record, as well as other crime-fighting achievements.
But did Gableman really fight northern Wisconsin arsonists—and win? An exhaustive search of online records in Wisconsin’s Consolidated Court Automation Programs (CCAP) database only turns up one arson case that Gableman put before a jury.
And Gableman lost the case. Calls to Gableman’s campaign, the Club for Growth and WMC to confirm their campaign statements went unreturned. What about Gableman’s other tough-on-crime successes? CCAP only lists nine individual felony jury cases naming Gableman as the prosecutor in Ashland County. Although nine different case numbers are listed, only six trials took place because some of the defendants had multiple cases that were consolidated.
These felony cases involved charges such as witness intimidation, sexual assault of a child, robbery, arson, substantial battery and felony child abuse. Gableman only managed to win two of those six trials—a theft from business and a sexual assault of a child case. Five years after winning the sexual assault case, the matter was dismissed on appeal to a higher court.
That leaves Gableman with only one successfully prosecuted felony jury case. So that’s the reality behind the campaign claims. But another reality is that state Supreme Court justices aren’t really crime-fighters who lock up the bad guys and throw out the key. Rather, they apply legal precedents to cases that have been tried by juries and appealed by lawyers— both prosecutors and defense attorneys who think that their clients have been wrongly convicted. (It has been known to happen. Would you want to change places with the innocent civil servant Georgia Thompson, who was convicted by a jury and served time in prison before her case was overturned by a federal appellate court?) So while right-wing groups such as the Club for Growth and WMC want to bamboozle voters into believing that a Supreme Court justice can single-handedly toss alleged arsonists and other baddies into jail, think again. That isn’t reality.
What’s your take? Write: editor@shepex.com.
Also in News Features:
It's Already Election DayWisconsin Voters Can Say Yes to Health Care ReformState Senate Update: Who Is Going to Win?Making the Bailout Less ToxicSaving Seminary WoodsActivist Julie Enslow Earns a Lifetime Peacemaker AwardBarack Obama’s WorldviewA Special Prosecutor for Wall StreetThe “Reform” McCain Wants to Forget“What You Get Is Incredible Rip-Offs”
..Search Shepherd Express
- Sat
11 - Sun
12 - Mon
13 - Tue
14 - Wed
15 - Thu
16 - Fri
17
Search in Events
2008-10-11 10:30am-2pm
Festivals
Select from over 2,000 original handcrafted bowls, sample delicious soups and breads from over 50 local chefs while listening to live music. Proceeds from your donation ($20 minimum per bowl including the Grab Bag Express, four bowl limits per person and $10 Kids' Bowls, no limit) will benefit food pantries and meal programs in the greater Milwaukee area.
Empty Bowls
Location: Central Milwaukee
Eighteen-year-old Ian Lafferty sets out on a cross country drive with his best
friends Lance and Felicia in order to lose his virginity to a red-hot babe he
met on the Internet. But the journey, filled wi
"Body of Lies" is based on "Washington Post" columnist David Ignatius' 2007
novel about a CIA operative, Roger Ferris, who uncovers a lead on a major
terrorist leader suspected to be operating out of J
Ry Cooder's California trilogy started purposefully and thematically with Chavez Ravine, turned old-time-radio wistful on My Name is Buddy, and now takes a complete header into the deep end for the concluding I, Flathead. Assuming the point of view
Genesis skipped Wisconsin during last year's reunion tour, but the three-DVD box set When In Rome 2007 spectacularly captures what we missed. Although original
frontman Peter Gabriel and guitarist Steve Hackett passed on this tour,
the incarnation
Michael Polaski’s Umami Moto is already a familiar dining spot in Brookfield, where it has gained note for its menu of Asian fusion. A second Umami Moto opened in downtown Milwaukee this summer, located on Milwaukee Street in the former Eve. This ti
The Painted Parrot (8028 W. National Ave.) is a fun, colorful restaurant that follows a Caribbean theme. Jamaican murals cover the walls and reggae music blasts from behind the large bar. The menu wanders through the Caribbean with a few Louisiana touches
Free Coupons!
Free Classifieds
Win the Chicago Getaway
Answer this Survey for a chance to Win $1,000
|
|
| Dining | |
| Contests | |
| Events | |
| Music | |
| A & E | |
| Film | |
| Film Times
|
|
| The New Economy
|
|
| Blogs/Voices | |
| Sports | |
| Weather | |
| Health Express | |
| Best of the City | |
| Free Classifieds |
Express Milwaukee Halloween Guide - Add Your Event
..Search Shepherd Express
